Salta al contenuto
Citiverse è uno spazio aperto a tutte le comunità. Se vuoi aprire un gruppo locale o una sezione per la tua organizzazione, puoi contattare gli amministratori: pagina dei contatti.

So, um, Tusky on Android let me make a Mastodon bio longer than 500 characters.

General Discussion
5 3 1
  • So, um, Tusky on Android let me make a Mastodon bio longer than 500 characters.

    On the standard Mastodon web client, the UI is shouting at me that I can't edit it unless I reduce it to 500 chars.

    I am guessing ActivityPub has no specific limit on a bio for a user, but can anyone tell me the risk/reward (and/or pros/cons) of making my bio > 500 chars?

    Like, will some clients/federated servers truncate at 500 chars?

  • So, um, Tusky on Android let me make a Mastodon bio longer than 500 characters.

    On the standard Mastodon web client, the UI is shouting at me that I can't edit it unless I reduce it to 500 chars.

    I am guessing ActivityPub has no specific limit on a bio for a user, but can anyone tell me the risk/reward (and/or pros/cons) of making my bio > 500 chars?

    Like, will some clients/federated servers truncate at 500 chars?

    @bkuhn
    Mastodon still displays long posts from other platforms with longer limits (1500 on my Hometown, 3000 on my Misskey). I would guess it's probably the same with account bios?

    If you have a doubt, it's possible to extend it with a pinned post, which will stay right after the bio and get seen by people who visit your profile.

  • @bkuhn
    Mastodon still displays long posts from other platforms with longer limits (1500 on my Hometown, 3000 on my Misskey). I would guess it's probably the same with account bios?

    If you have a doubt, it's possible to extend it with a pinned post, which will stay right after the bio and get seen by people who visit your profile.

    @TerryHancock

    Yeah, I do have stuff of importance in pinned posts already. But ultimately I suspect that a lot of people stop reading at the end of the bio.

    What fascinated me and led me to ask was that Tusky (which AFAIK is a Mastodon-specific client) let me edit the bio past 500 chars, and the web client does not.

    I see posts from non-Mastodon ActivityPub implementations that do display with "Read more" in Mastodon, but never seen that in a bio (yet). My > 500 char bio displays in full.

  • @TerryHancock

    Yeah, I do have stuff of importance in pinned posts already. But ultimately I suspect that a lot of people stop reading at the end of the bio.

    What fascinated me and led me to ask was that Tusky (which AFAIK is a Mastodon-specific client) let me edit the bio past 500 chars, and the web client does not.

    I see posts from non-Mastodon ActivityPub implementations that do display with "Read more" in Mastodon, but never seen that in a bio (yet). My > 500 char bio displays in full.

    @bkuhn @TerryHancock Glad to see I'm not the only one that noticed that. I had written up a somewhat lengthy bio in , then a few months later, wanted to tweak it on the desktop web client. Got a complaint upon trying to save about the 500-character limit. Presumably it was just a client-side restriction, since the existing bio displayed in full.

    But I didn't want to wrestle with it, so I just pared down my bio to less than 500 characters.

  • @bkuhn @TerryHancock Glad to see I'm not the only one that noticed that. I had written up a somewhat lengthy bio in , then a few months later, wanted to tweak it on the desktop web client. Got a complaint upon trying to save about the 500-character limit. Presumably it was just a client-side restriction, since the existing bio displayed in full.

    But I didn't want to wrestle with it, so I just pared down my bio to less than 500 characters.

    @aspensmonster

    It's not really a client bug per se, since philosophy is to keep the 500 char limit for everything (which I fully support, as one of the big reasons I enjoy (which we all once upon a time called -ing, remeber?) is that it helps me practice concision in my writing — a skill I struggle with.

    I think it's just a UI bug on both sides: should warn but not stop you at 500, & web client should indicate you have to edit with a different client.


Citiverse è un progetto che si basa su NodeBB ed è federato! | Categorie federate | Chat | 📱 Installa web app o APK | 🧡 Donazioni | Privacy Policy

Il server utilizzato è quello di Webdock, in Danimarca. Se volete provarlo potete ottenere il 20% di sconto con questo link e noi riceveremo un aiuto sotto forma di credito da usare proprio per mantenere Citiverse.