Salta al contenuto
Citiverse è uno spazio aperto a tutte le comunità. Se vuoi aprire un gruppo locale o una sezione per la tua organizzazione, puoi contattare gli amministratori: pagina dei contatti.

I think being politically intolerant in 2026 makes zero practical sense

Fediverse
11 8 14
  • [[topic:post-is-deleted]]
    scritto ultima modifica di supersquirrel@lemmy.ca
    #2

    I like to boil reality down to something really basic: the left (liberal, whatever) pushes us toward progress, which is good, but bad if it’s blind. The right (conservative) tests whether that progress can hold up. So both sides balance the world, at least in my naive little worldview.

    Your axiomatic assertion here is naive and worse it involves you projecting something you desperately want to be true onto a reality that doesn't fit.

    What do you mean by "balance" anyways? Deadlock? Performative division masking lockstep conformity?

  • I like to boil reality down to something really basic: the left (liberal, whatever) pushes us toward progress, which is good, but bad if it’s blind. The right (conservative) tests whether that progress can hold up. So both sides balance the world, at least in my naive little worldview.

    Your axiomatic assertion here is naive and worse it involves you projecting something you desperately want to be true onto a reality that doesn't fit.

    What do you mean by "balance" anyways? Deadlock? Performative division masking lockstep conformity?

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #3

    Fair point, it’s a simplification. I said so in the post, and I know reality is a lot messier.

    By “balance” I just mean each side keeping the other’s extremes in check, not a deadlock. Maybe it doesn’t always work that way, but that’s the idea.

    But “the right” is just as broad a label as mine. Conservatives, libertarians, and authoritarian regimes aren’t the same thing. If you mean specific groups, name them and let’s talk about those.

    Performative division masking lockstep conformity?

    Yes. that's right. I don’t get why you’d fight someone who’s dealing with the same oppression firsthand, even if they see the world differently. (And that’s something we have in common: I’m against violence and oppression too. It’s an extreme, no matter which side it comes from)

  • I like to boil reality down to something really basic: the left (liberal, whatever) pushes us toward progress, which is good, but bad if it’s blind. The right (conservative) tests whether that progress can hold up. So both sides balance the world, at least in my naive little worldview.

    Your axiomatic assertion here is naive and worse it involves you projecting something you desperately want to be true onto a reality that doesn't fit.

    What do you mean by "balance" anyways? Deadlock? Performative division masking lockstep conformity?

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #4

    The main point of my post is that the echo chamber is also a common enemy, even though I don't really like using this word.

  • [[topic:post-is-deleted]]
    scritto ultima modifica di steve@communick.news
    #5
    1. Say you're politically intolerant toward someone with the opposite views. But you live at about the same standard of living, eat the same food, go to school in about the same places, hang out in the same spots, and doomscroll the same garbage. Don't you share the same problems?

    Not at all.
    First: It's unlikely you'll doomscroll the same garbage. Social feeds are highly customized and curated. You'll likely have entirely different ideas in your feeds.
    Second: Being in the same place doesn't mean you have the same goals and desires. Our problems are very much defined by what we want.

    1. Even if you're sure you're right and everyone else is an oppressor, a troll, or a virgin, doesn't that make you exactly like your opponent?

    When someone thinks "everyone" is something, it's frequently because they themselves are that thing. But in political fights it's frequently between someone who thinks everyone is (or should be) something, and someone who thinks people are all different, and society should allow for those differences.

    So no, arguing against oppression doesn't make you an oppressor.

    1. We're kinda cooked, bro. The world we live in has gotten heavier, gone nuts, and is rolling downhill with no one knowing where it ends up. On our own, we don't have the resources or the moral strength to face what's coming.

    It's not going to "end up". It'll always keep rolling. (Relative to human scale measures of time, anyway) But many know where it's going. The rolling is targeted. It's being deliberately guided downhill by people who'll benefit from that. There are others trying to change its course tward someplace better for most of us. But neither group is blind of the landscape, or course of the boulder.

  • Fair point, it’s a simplification. I said so in the post, and I know reality is a lot messier.

    By “balance” I just mean each side keeping the other’s extremes in check, not a deadlock. Maybe it doesn’t always work that way, but that’s the idea.

    But “the right” is just as broad a label as mine. Conservatives, libertarians, and authoritarian regimes aren’t the same thing. If you mean specific groups, name them and let’s talk about those.

    Performative division masking lockstep conformity?

    Yes. that's right. I don’t get why you’d fight someone who’s dealing with the same oppression firsthand, even if they see the world differently. (And that’s something we have in common: I’m against violence and oppression too. It’s an extreme, no matter which side it comes from)

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #6

    Yes. that's right. I don’t get why you’d fight someone who’s dealing with the same oppression firsthand, even if they see the world differently. (And that’s something we have in common: I’m against violence and oppression too. It’s an extreme, no matter which side it comes from)

    The left are the "side" that is trying to address these issue. The right is the side that wants to make things objectively worse for everyone except the ruling class. You're against violence and oppression, the "right" loves that, not just the far right, but they have always supported more policing. The extreme left is also bad for that, the extreme left and right have a lot in common

  • [[topic:post-is-deleted]]
    scritto ultima modifica di
    #7

    The Big Interest and the right-wing are always on the same side, have you not noticed that? The corporations, the current path for technology, the tracking, the attention manipulation, that's all being done by right-wingers and benefits right-wing politics.

  • [[topic:post-is-deleted]]
    scritto ultima modifica di
    #8

    I don't know why you were downvoted; you obviously put effort into articulating a position that you are working through. Maybe it's because of the community you posted to?

    Well, screw the downvoters. Thanks for laying this out. It's good work. It needs to be discussed. You probably aren't alone in your formulation.

    What I would say is that your formulation has flaws that, if you are open to being wrong, or even just changing your understanding (and therefore your beliefs), then you're going to find a path towards something that is more accurate

    The challenge with developing that accuracy is that we generally experience that development as individuals. Especially in the internet media world, you raising your own consciousness is not a collaborative process for the most part, it's an individual one. And that's somewhat fine - mass consciousness raising is the aggregate of many individual consciousness raising. The problem, which I think your articulation points to, is that if you raise your consciousness and develop a more accurate set of beliefs, you become one of the people that previously you were resisting or critiquing. And if that's true for you, then it's true for all the very many people who think like you do now. If you raise your consciousness individually, then all the people who think like you now suddenly see you as someone who has it wrong.

    So to all the commenters who want to argue against your inaccurate beliefs, we're missing a an opportunity to do something different here. Whether David's beliefs become more accurate is far less important than whether people like David en masse develop more accurate beliefs.

    So I want to ask you, David. If we can convince that your beliefs are inaccurate, but not try to impose our beliefs on you, 3 questions:

    1. how would you go about developing more accurate beliefs?
    2. how could you do that in community with others who are like-minded with you?
    3. how could we support you and your community in more safely and more effectively exploring these domains and raising your consciousness?

    Discussion forums like this have a few modalities for raising individual consciousness: memes, debate, ridicule, and information sharing. Mass consciousness raising happens by virtue of doing these things in public for others to observe happening, or by using information sharing to organize deliberate communities of collaborative consciousness raising (like reading groups).

    But if you could get 3 other people who thought the way you do, how would you go about collaborating with them to raise your consciousness together to get more accurate beliefs about the world? What would help you get there? What challenges do you face? What's in the way?

    Because I agree with you - nearly everyone you and I come in contact with are in the same group of people suffering under the same structural system that harms us and we all suffer together and we will all liberate each other together. The main difference is the difference in our understanding of the world and how we all relate to eachother and the world. If we can come together in order to co-produce a more accurate understanding, then we can be a lot more effective even in the face of differences in belief and opinion. We need movement towards more accurate shared beliefs.

  • The main point of my post is that the echo chamber is also a common enemy, even though I don't really like using this word.

    scritto ultima modifica di supersquirrel@lemmy.ca
    #9

    This is an echo chamber

    This is the opposite of an echo chamber

    The "echo chamber" metaphor is almost exclusively used to incorrectly portray communities with a structure like open cell foam with many smaller semiconnected communities as prone to producing echoes when it is the precise opposite structure of large open cavernous spaces bounded by hard surfaces (groups where everyone is always talking to everyone else equally) that produce echoes.

    Fragmentation does not produce echoes, creating large silos bounded by thick inflexible surfaces does.

  • [[topic:post-is-deleted]]
    scritto ultima modifica di
    #10

    Behold, the paradox of tolerance made manifest!

  • [[topic:post-is-deleted]]
    scritto ultima modifica di
    #11

    I think being tolerant of overtly intolerant of political ideologies makes zero practical sense.

  • Same old, same old

    General Discussion fediverse cinéma movies films letterboxd neodb moviebuff
    1
    0 Votazioni
    1 Post
    11 Visualizzazioni
    Nessuno ha risposto
  • i feel like lemmy has broken the promise of the fediverse

    Fediverse fediverse
    37
    23 Votazioni
    37 Post
    36 Visualizzazioni
    die4ever@retrolemmy.comD
    When you make a Mastodon post, put @berlin@feddit.org at the bottom and that will do what you want
  • Support a creator you follow today!

    Fediverse fediverse
    1
    10 Votazioni
    1 Post
    10 Visualizzazioni
    Nessuno ha risposto
  • 20 Votazioni
    26 Post
    52 Visualizzazioni
    sxan@piefed.zipS
    It does, but þe community has to have a rule. I haven't seen such a rule in any community where FOSS announcements tend to be made. My post was specifically about slopcoded projects, implicitly FOSS projects.
  • 0 Votazioni
    3 Post
    51 Visualizzazioni
    ?
    @thefoggiest Never! You never know when you’ll need one while hitchhiking across the Fediverse.
  • 13 Votazioni
    3 Post
    39 Visualizzazioni
    snoopy@tarte.nuage-libre.frS
    Piefed needs some translation update : https://translate.piefed.social Any help for the piefed wiki is also appreciated just ping me if you want to help me.
  • What is a Fediverse "community"?

    General Discussion fediverse activitypub community
    10
    0 Votazioni
    10 Post
    45 Visualizzazioni
    smallcircles@social.coopS
    @steve Perhaps it is proper #ActivityPub Groups support. Lemmy already calls that "Community". And perhaps the retracted FEP-2100: Unbound Group and Organization to have Groups be independent of instances / multi-instance spanning, can be implemented in mainstream fedi to have a real fedi native concept of Groups (i.e. the abstract concept, not depending on an implementation detail)..https://fediverse.codeberg.page/fep/fep/2100
  • 2 Votazioni
    102 Post
    103 Visualizzazioni
    openstars@piefed.socialO
    It's been a couple weeks and I wanted to add another perspective about this. I noticed a user downvoting posts, https://lemvotes.org/user/FarStare@lemmy.dbzer0.com if it helps to have specifics. In the more than one full year of existing, they have never once contributed via making a post, never once commenting even, just doling out up- and down-votes in roughly equal proportion, and even those nearly exclusively via posts but almost never comments. I am not concerned about receiving votes from PugJesus - either up or down, as PugJesus has earned the right to speak on behalf of the community. But who is this other person who is influencing how others see my content? Are they male or female? Do they have a degree of some kind? Do they primarily visit meme communities, as the vote pattern might suggest, or other communities as well? So how do I feel about people who use the Threadiverse more than others? My answer is more complex and nuanced than simply yay or nay. I might prefer the opposite of the implemented feature even - the more someone posts (including comments?), the more upvotes they are allowed to make? Have they not earned such? Also, if votes were exposed, each individual could decide for themselves how they wanted to make use of voting - perhaps someone would ban PugJesus, or conversely write special code (a 3rd party app / API recipient?) to highlight posts that PugJesus upvoted (isn't that how "boosting" works? at least re-tweeting does). It's really difficult to guess what someone wants, as each person wants different things. Which is why ultimately in an effort to make things more fair & equitable, the solution can end up making it less so. I like the follow-up suggestion to leave this new option OFF by default, so that an instance admin would have to specifically opt-in, perhaps as part of an overall suite of features limiting things like posts and comments as well. Although really, I think other approaches might work better - e.g. why would someone want to limit themselves to "some" of PugJesus' content, wouldn't they rather simply have it all or else ban him from the instance and therefore have none? I am not seeing the benefit realistically of having "some", especially when the delimiter is not based on community or overall content but simply what time of day (based on an arbitrary threshold for when they starts and ends to restart the next period) the votes are cast?

Citiverse è un progetto che si basa su NodeBB ed è federato! | Categorie federate | Chat | 📱 Installa web app o APK | 🧡 Donazioni | Privacy Policy

Il server utilizzato è quello di Webdock, in Danimarca. Se volete provarlo potete ottenere il 20% di sconto con questo link e noi riceveremo un aiuto sotto forma di credito da usare proprio per mantenere Citiverse.