Salta al contenuto
Citiverse è uno spazio aperto a tutte le comunità. Se vuoi aprire un gruppo locale o una sezione per la tua organizzazione, puoi contattare gli amministratori: pagina dei contatti.

Lemmy is copying the worst feature that ruined Reddit

Fediverse
103 47 8
  • scritto ultima modifica di
    #1

    I'm splitting this into two parts. First identifying the issue. And second my personal idea for a solution. I'm hoping for a lot of discussion so please be clear which part you are responding to.

    Part 1: The problem

    Reddit as a platform has many flaws. Obviously being a corporation means they're terrible no matter what. But their platform is also flawed. Even if Reddit was 100% community owned the platform would still be flawed. The number one thing that is ruining Reddit are the tyrannical mods.

    Each community on Reddit is a dictatorship. Whoever is arbitrarily in charge of a community has full unrestricted power to do whatever they want. The people who are actually creating the content and sharing it are totally at their whim. I understand that modding is a difficult and thankless job, but toxic mods ruined Reddit and Lemmy will do the same if it's not addressed.

    Lemmy's answer is to allow people to create their own instances. Don't like the mods at World? Go make your own Lemmy, with blackjack and hookers. But that's not sufficient. It takes years to build up a community to have enough people for meaningful discussion to happen, and nearly all communities or instances fail. We absolutely need a way for mods to answer to the users.

    Part 2: My solution

    My solution is simple. Lemmy is built on the community. Everyone helps run it. Therefore mods are elected by the users who generate the highest upvoted content in a community.

    Elections should happen on a schedule and, if a community is particularly upset with a mod, a vote of no confidence can be taken.

    I understand that this will be a huge undertaking. But I truly believe that we need to fix this issue for Lemmy to thrive long term. Or else we'll just end up with another Reddit.

  • I'm splitting this into two parts. First identifying the issue. And second my personal idea for a solution. I'm hoping for a lot of discussion so please be clear which part you are responding to.

    Part 1: The problem

    Reddit as a platform has many flaws. Obviously being a corporation means they're terrible no matter what. But their platform is also flawed. Even if Reddit was 100% community owned the platform would still be flawed. The number one thing that is ruining Reddit are the tyrannical mods.

    Each community on Reddit is a dictatorship. Whoever is arbitrarily in charge of a community has full unrestricted power to do whatever they want. The people who are actually creating the content and sharing it are totally at their whim. I understand that modding is a difficult and thankless job, but toxic mods ruined Reddit and Lemmy will do the same if it's not addressed.

    Lemmy's answer is to allow people to create their own instances. Don't like the mods at World? Go make your own Lemmy, with blackjack and hookers. But that's not sufficient. It takes years to build up a community to have enough people for meaningful discussion to happen, and nearly all communities or instances fail. We absolutely need a way for mods to answer to the users.

    Part 2: My solution

    My solution is simple. Lemmy is built on the community. Everyone helps run it. Therefore mods are elected by the users who generate the highest upvoted content in a community.

    Elections should happen on a schedule and, if a community is particularly upset with a mod, a vote of no confidence can be taken.

    I understand that this will be a huge undertaking. But I truly believe that we need to fix this issue for Lemmy to thrive long term. Or else we'll just end up with another Reddit.

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #2

    So your probelm with the platforms is not the platforms themselves, but people? Because the mods running communities here aren't too different from the refit communities.

    As for your second point, you want karma farmers to run the communities?

  • I'm splitting this into two parts. First identifying the issue. And second my personal idea for a solution. I'm hoping for a lot of discussion so please be clear which part you are responding to.

    Part 1: The problem

    Reddit as a platform has many flaws. Obviously being a corporation means they're terrible no matter what. But their platform is also flawed. Even if Reddit was 100% community owned the platform would still be flawed. The number one thing that is ruining Reddit are the tyrannical mods.

    Each community on Reddit is a dictatorship. Whoever is arbitrarily in charge of a community has full unrestricted power to do whatever they want. The people who are actually creating the content and sharing it are totally at their whim. I understand that modding is a difficult and thankless job, but toxic mods ruined Reddit and Lemmy will do the same if it's not addressed.

    Lemmy's answer is to allow people to create their own instances. Don't like the mods at World? Go make your own Lemmy, with blackjack and hookers. But that's not sufficient. It takes years to build up a community to have enough people for meaningful discussion to happen, and nearly all communities or instances fail. We absolutely need a way for mods to answer to the users.

    Part 2: My solution

    My solution is simple. Lemmy is built on the community. Everyone helps run it. Therefore mods are elected by the users who generate the highest upvoted content in a community.

    Elections should happen on a schedule and, if a community is particularly upset with a mod, a vote of no confidence can be taken.

    I understand that this will be a huge undertaking. But I truly believe that we need to fix this issue for Lemmy to thrive long term. Or else we'll just end up with another Reddit.

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #3

    My second solution, which may be too radical, is simply do away with mods. Each community gets a threshold of upvotes to downvotes and anything that's outside of that range is removed.

    There are some obvious downsides with this idea. Sometimes content needs to be rapidly removed. It also opens ideological communities to attacks where good content is removed because people who disagree with it downvote it

  • I'm splitting this into two parts. First identifying the issue. And second my personal idea for a solution. I'm hoping for a lot of discussion so please be clear which part you are responding to.

    Part 1: The problem

    Reddit as a platform has many flaws. Obviously being a corporation means they're terrible no matter what. But their platform is also flawed. Even if Reddit was 100% community owned the platform would still be flawed. The number one thing that is ruining Reddit are the tyrannical mods.

    Each community on Reddit is a dictatorship. Whoever is arbitrarily in charge of a community has full unrestricted power to do whatever they want. The people who are actually creating the content and sharing it are totally at their whim. I understand that modding is a difficult and thankless job, but toxic mods ruined Reddit and Lemmy will do the same if it's not addressed.

    Lemmy's answer is to allow people to create their own instances. Don't like the mods at World? Go make your own Lemmy, with blackjack and hookers. But that's not sufficient. It takes years to build up a community to have enough people for meaningful discussion to happen, and nearly all communities or instances fail. We absolutely need a way for mods to answer to the users.

    Part 2: My solution

    My solution is simple. Lemmy is built on the community. Everyone helps run it. Therefore mods are elected by the users who generate the highest upvoted content in a community.

    Elections should happen on a schedule and, if a community is particularly upset with a mod, a vote of no confidence can be taken.

    I understand that this will be a huge undertaking. But I truly believe that we need to fix this issue for Lemmy to thrive long term. Or else we'll just end up with another Reddit.

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #4

    IMHO, most Lemmy mods are fine. And it doesn't take years to advertise your community. The end.

  • So your probelm with the platforms is not the platforms themselves, but people? Because the mods running communities here aren't too different from the refit communities.

    As for your second point, you want karma farmers to run the communities?

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #5

    As I said, Reddit is a corporation so it will never be good even if their platform had no flaws.

    I'm open to feedback on my solution, please provide your opinion on how it can be improved to address the weaknesses you're seeing.

  • IMHO, most Lemmy mods are fine. And it doesn't take years to advertise your community. The end.

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #6

    Most Reddit mods were fine at one point as well. In your estimation, if I wanted to start a Lemmy community for something niche say bonsai tree triming, how long would it take to get enough people for real discussions?

  • My second solution, which may be too radical, is simply do away with mods. Each community gets a threshold of upvotes to downvotes and anything that's outside of that range is removed.

    There are some obvious downsides with this idea. Sometimes content needs to be rapidly removed. It also opens ideological communities to attacks where good content is removed because people who disagree with it downvote it

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #7

    Sounds like the easiest idea to put in place.

  • Sounds like the easiest idea to put in place.

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #8

    Easy yes, but the flaws will need to be addressed. Maybe mods have limited removal powers?

  • I'm splitting this into two parts. First identifying the issue. And second my personal idea for a solution. I'm hoping for a lot of discussion so please be clear which part you are responding to.

    Part 1: The problem

    Reddit as a platform has many flaws. Obviously being a corporation means they're terrible no matter what. But their platform is also flawed. Even if Reddit was 100% community owned the platform would still be flawed. The number one thing that is ruining Reddit are the tyrannical mods.

    Each community on Reddit is a dictatorship. Whoever is arbitrarily in charge of a community has full unrestricted power to do whatever they want. The people who are actually creating the content and sharing it are totally at their whim. I understand that modding is a difficult and thankless job, but toxic mods ruined Reddit and Lemmy will do the same if it's not addressed.

    Lemmy's answer is to allow people to create their own instances. Don't like the mods at World? Go make your own Lemmy, with blackjack and hookers. But that's not sufficient. It takes years to build up a community to have enough people for meaningful discussion to happen, and nearly all communities or instances fail. We absolutely need a way for mods to answer to the users.

    Part 2: My solution

    My solution is simple. Lemmy is built on the community. Everyone helps run it. Therefore mods are elected by the users who generate the highest upvoted content in a community.

    Elections should happen on a schedule and, if a community is particularly upset with a mod, a vote of no confidence can be taken.

    I understand that this will be a huge undertaking. But I truly believe that we need to fix this issue for Lemmy to thrive long term. Or else we'll just end up with another Reddit.

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #9

    Obviously being a corporation means they're terrible no matter what. Even if Reddit was 100% community owned

    It would still be a corporation. Do you realise unions, non-profit NGOs, churches, and every legal entity that isn't a literal human, is a corporation?

    toxic mods ruined Reddit

    No they didn't. At most they ruined their community. But anyone can make another community on Reddit. Doubly so here on Lemmy.

  • My second solution, which may be too radical, is simply do away with mods. Each community gets a threshold of upvotes to downvotes and anything that's outside of that range is removed.

    There are some obvious downsides with this idea. Sometimes content needs to be rapidly removed. It also opens ideological communities to attacks where good content is removed because people who disagree with it downvote it

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #10

    Lemmy is open source. You could start an instance and run it this way, as a trial.

    I'm not sure it would work. It's very hard to effectively replace volunteer effort with an algorithm.

  • Most Reddit mods were fine at one point as well. In your estimation, if I wanted to start a Lemmy community for something niche say bonsai tree triming, how long would it take to get enough people for real discussions?

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #11

    1 week. Advertise and I'm pretty sure bonsai people will come. If they don't exist or are not there, you will have no discussion anyway.

  • Obviously being a corporation means they're terrible no matter what. Even if Reddit was 100% community owned

    It would still be a corporation. Do you realise unions, non-profit NGOs, churches, and every legal entity that isn't a literal human, is a corporation?

    toxic mods ruined Reddit

    No they didn't. At most they ruined their community. But anyone can make another community on Reddit. Doubly so here on Lemmy.

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #12

    Wow you got me I used the popular definition of corporation and not the technically correct one good job /s

    If you feel like mods haven't ruined Reddit you must have not attempted to post on a popular community for at least several years. Go try it.

  • 1 week. Advertise and I'm pretty sure bonsai people will come. If they don't exist or are not there, you will have no discussion anyway.

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #13

    I'd love to see it if you're willing to demonstrate

  • As I said, Reddit is a corporation so it will never be good even if their platform had no flaws.

    I'm open to feedback on my solution, please provide your opinion on how it can be improved to address the weaknesses you're seeing.

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #14

    feedback on my solution

    He gave you a good one but I'll explain: there is no karma here. But spammers have a lot of accounts, which would mean one spammer would be able to elect himself which is not what we want.

  • Lemmy is open source. You could start an instance and run it this way, as a trial.

    I'm not sure it would work. It's very hard to effectively replace volunteer effort with an algorithm.

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #15

    Yeah trialing it on specific instances first is definitely a good idea.

  • feedback on my solution

    He gave you a good one but I'll explain: there is no karma here. But spammers have a lot of accounts, which would mean one spammer would be able to elect himself which is not what we want.

    scritto ultima modifica di lemmysuxnow@reddthat.com
    #16

    Yeah that's true. I guess I'm assuming people aren't upvoting spam. What could be a better way to qualify who is allowed to vote for a community's mods?

  • I'd love to see it if you're willing to demonstrate

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #17

    I'm not because I don't have time for this. Feel free to do it. Back in the late 90s we had small communities and it was fun. No one wondered how we could attract hundreds of people from other forums.

  • I'm not because I don't have time for this. Feel free to do it. Back in the late 90s we had small communities and it was fun. No one wondered how we could attract hundreds of people from other forums.

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #18

    Sadly it is no longer the 90s

  • I'm splitting this into two parts. First identifying the issue. And second my personal idea for a solution. I'm hoping for a lot of discussion so please be clear which part you are responding to.

    Part 1: The problem

    Reddit as a platform has many flaws. Obviously being a corporation means they're terrible no matter what. But their platform is also flawed. Even if Reddit was 100% community owned the platform would still be flawed. The number one thing that is ruining Reddit are the tyrannical mods.

    Each community on Reddit is a dictatorship. Whoever is arbitrarily in charge of a community has full unrestricted power to do whatever they want. The people who are actually creating the content and sharing it are totally at their whim. I understand that modding is a difficult and thankless job, but toxic mods ruined Reddit and Lemmy will do the same if it's not addressed.

    Lemmy's answer is to allow people to create their own instances. Don't like the mods at World? Go make your own Lemmy, with blackjack and hookers. But that's not sufficient. It takes years to build up a community to have enough people for meaningful discussion to happen, and nearly all communities or instances fail. We absolutely need a way for mods to answer to the users.

    Part 2: My solution

    My solution is simple. Lemmy is built on the community. Everyone helps run it. Therefore mods are elected by the users who generate the highest upvoted content in a community.

    Elections should happen on a schedule and, if a community is particularly upset with a mod, a vote of no confidence can be taken.

    I understand that this will be a huge undertaking. But I truly believe that we need to fix this issue for Lemmy to thrive long term. Or else we'll just end up with another Reddit.

    scritto ultima modifica di schnurrito@discuss.tchncs.de
    #19

    That will just make sure that it will be impossible to create niche communities about unpopular ideas, if (the same) majorities can vote mods out. To take an analogy from the offline world: democracy is a very good and necessary thing for running a government because there can be only one government in a specific territory. But corporations are not (normally) run democratically, instead we allow different ones to compete and people to be customers or employees at whichever of them does things best. Lemmy communities are like corporations, not like governments: there can be more than one of them and we can individually choose which ones to be parts of.

    The status quo is roughly fine in this regard. We've had the concept of moderators being appointed from above since I started to be on the Internet at all (more than 20 years ago), back then it was on a lot of independent forums.

  • I'm splitting this into two parts. First identifying the issue. And second my personal idea for a solution. I'm hoping for a lot of discussion so please be clear which part you are responding to.

    Part 1: The problem

    Reddit as a platform has many flaws. Obviously being a corporation means they're terrible no matter what. But their platform is also flawed. Even if Reddit was 100% community owned the platform would still be flawed. The number one thing that is ruining Reddit are the tyrannical mods.

    Each community on Reddit is a dictatorship. Whoever is arbitrarily in charge of a community has full unrestricted power to do whatever they want. The people who are actually creating the content and sharing it are totally at their whim. I understand that modding is a difficult and thankless job, but toxic mods ruined Reddit and Lemmy will do the same if it's not addressed.

    Lemmy's answer is to allow people to create their own instances. Don't like the mods at World? Go make your own Lemmy, with blackjack and hookers. But that's not sufficient. It takes years to build up a community to have enough people for meaningful discussion to happen, and nearly all communities or instances fail. We absolutely need a way for mods to answer to the users.

    Part 2: My solution

    My solution is simple. Lemmy is built on the community. Everyone helps run it. Therefore mods are elected by the users who generate the highest upvoted content in a community.

    Elections should happen on a schedule and, if a community is particularly upset with a mod, a vote of no confidence can be taken.

    I understand that this will be a huge undertaking. But I truly believe that we need to fix this issue for Lemmy to thrive long term. Or else we'll just end up with another Reddit.

    scritto ultima modifica di
    #20

    Literally nothing is stopping you from creating communities or even an entire instance that follows that principle...

    If you want to do it, then do it.

    And if people want it, they'll participate.

    But even if they do, I don't think you'll get the result you expect and want


Citiverse è un progetto che si basa su NodeBB ed è federato! | Categorie federate | Chat | 📱 Installa web app o APK | 🧡 Donazioni | Privacy Policy

Il server utilizzato è quello di Webdock, in Danimarca. Se volete provarlo potete ottenere il 20% di sconto con questo link e noi riceveremo un aiuto sotto forma di credito da usare proprio per mantenere Citiverse.